Because I just couldn't leave well enough alone, I decided to place another order and try some different colors and styles. Cue gratuitous face shots (I promise after this I'll take a break for awhile, seeing your face show up on google images is kind of startling):
Crosby in Revolver Black - Initially didn't catch my eye, but these are the boyfriends favorite which obviously makes me do a rethink.
Webb in Whiskey Tortoise Matte - The style I chose as number 1 in the color I thought I'd love... meh.
Griffin in Revolver Black - Sorta dopey but I kind of love them.
Winston in Revolver Black - Similar to first pair, but boyfriend says "too Run DMC".
Sinclair in Greystone - I quite like this color but the shape does nothing for me.
So after all the try-ons and opinions... I am obscenely confused. Go with the first pair I loved (Webb)? Dorky but awesome pair (Griffin)? Trust the boyfriends instincts (Crosby)? Help (?)??